Rushmore Rejects · Album Three · 23 October 2026
Benjamin Harrison, 23rd President of the United States
“We want no more of humbug,
For we've had enough of that.
We want no human iceberg,
And we want no grandpa's hat.”
“Labor's Voice,” credited to the New York World, reprinted in the
West Virginia Argus (Kingwood, W.Va.), 28 July 1892, p. 1.
Library of Congress, Chronicling America.
One Democratic campaign stanza carries both insults that followed Harrison out of office and into obscurity: that he was cold, and that he was small enough to be wearing a dead man's hat. This record is named after half of it. Every claim sung here is sourced below, including the ones that turned out not to be true.
Listen to The Human IcebergHe is the first president whose voice survives. You can hear him, and you still don't know who he is.
Grandfather was president for thirty-one days. Democrats said the hat was too big for the boy's head; his own party wrote a song insisting it fit. Nobody said his name.
He revived the front-porch campaign and never left Indianapolis. The country came to the house.
The epithet, and the coldness that can actually be attributed to a named man.
Electricity arrives in 1891. The family will not touch the switches.
Magnificent to ten thousand strangers. Fatal to one man in a room.
She returned to the White House to die, fourteen days before the election, with the china unfinished and the house unbuilt. Her track is not withdrawal; it is occupation.
He bought the grandchildren a goat. The goat is better remembered than he is.
The strongest moral material in his record, and it is a record of defeat. One vote. That's all it ever is.
He redrew the flag more than anyone who ever held the office, and nobody has looked at it and thought of him since.
In 1882 he voted against it. In 1892 he signed the harsher version. The same law appears on two consecutive records in this series, and so does the retreat.
The same man on both sides of him. He won without the country and lost with it.
The cylinder returns, uncut, and has earned the room. It kept him, and forgot him anyway.
A concept album about a forgotten man is under permanent temptation to improve him. These are the best stories about Benjamin Harrison, and they are left off the record because no primary or institutional source could be found for them.
More liner notes: Gentleman Boss · Handsome Frank
River Road Labs